Damning new evidence shows that Tory prison reform is a scam

The number of assaults on prison staff in England and Wales has increased over the last two years. Such assaults are causing very real concerns, and are tearing apart a Conservative policy on prison reform that will ultimately see communities suffer.

Damning figures

GetWestLondon, a Trinity Mirror publication, requested details around the number of convicts that attacked staff at various prison institutions from the Ministry of Justice. The information has revealed that the number of assaults on staff reaches into the thousands.

Uncovered data showed that a number of inmates across the country attacked staff on multiple occasions within a one year period. At least five prisoners, for instance, seriously assaulted prison guards at least four times in 2015 at HMP Feltham.

Other data includes 29 attacks at HMP Bronzefield and 10 assaults at HMP High Down. It also shows that, in many cases, the same prisoner was responsible for multiple assaults within the year.

In total, there were 4,963 assaults on staff in England and Wales in 2015. But between October 2015 and September 2016, there were 6,430 assaults. This indicates much higher figures for 2016.

According to the paper, a Prison Service spokesperson said:

We do not tolerate any violence against the dedicated staff that work with our offenders.

When incidents like this occur we work closely with the police to push for the strongest possible punishment.

We are reforming our prisons and have taken immediate action to tackle the drugs, drones and phones that undermine security. We are also investing £100m annually to boost the front-line by 2,500 officers.

These are long-standing issues that will not be resolved in weeks or months, but our wholesale reforms will lay the groundwork to transform our prisons, reduce re-offending, and make our communities safer.

How will the Tories resolve it?

The rising figures come in time for an address by Justice Secretary Liz Truss at the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ) on 13 February. The CSJ is a thinktank that makes “policy recommendations to tackle the root causes of poverty”.

Truss says:

Public protection is paramount, which means managing the prison population in a safe and sustainable way.

So over time the prison population will go down if Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service has got better at reforming offenders. It will go down if we have got better at intervening earlier. And it will go down if we have got better at managing the population inside.

Truss is suggesting that halving the prisons population is at the heart of reform and rehabilitation is the way to do this. And the forthcoming Prisons and Courts Bill “will for the first time enshrine in law that reforming offenders is a key purpose of prison and that the Secretary of State has a responsibility for delivering it”.

The catch

Truss is saying the right words and putting in more money. She has promised to boost frontline officers by 2,500, inject £1.3bn into overall prison reform, and include better and more modern buildings.

But it comes after £900m in cuts between 2010/11 and 2014/15, and a drop of 9,470 staff between 2011 and 2016. None of these cuts involved building downgrades, so the shortfall is in service provision.

Understaffing and underfunding have had violent results. As well as the risk to prison staff, there has been abuse, fights, riots, suicides, and deaths. This prevalence of violence means confining prisoners for longer and repeating the cycle of violence.

The costs of maintaining each prisoner is £33,291, and overcrowding and understaffing means proper rehabilitation does not take place. So those going back out into the community are more likely to reoffend and go back into prison. And while Truss is committing to rehabilitation, a key report suggests the government is already failing on its previous commitments in this area.

Failing to put words into action

Truss’s words are therefore failing to turn into action.

It also means that the Tories are banking on prison populations going down in the future. This omits in their mind the need for serious funding right now in order to adequately staff prisons. The exact funding that was taken away.

The release of these damning figures speaks volumes. The figures show the harm to people whichever way you look at it. Communities are hurt when they are less safe. Prisoners are hurt when they are more vulnerable. And frontline staff, like prison officers, are hurt when they don’t have the resources to protect themselves.

By driving home the need to rehabilitate and push prison populations down in the future, she has deflected the need for resources right now.

Get Involved!

– Find out how you can support crime reduction organisations like the Howard League for Penal Reform.

– Read more Canary articles on justice and prisons.

Featured image via Flickr/ Wikimedia Commons